Huge Explosion Caused Global Warming?

| | Comments (1)

Vladimir Shaidurov of the Russian Academy of Sciences claims that our current global warming is due to changes in the level of atmospheric water amounts caused by the Tunguska Event in Siberia in 1908. Hmmm.

1 Comments

I'm not buying it. A number of lines of evidence, including Canadian ice thickness data, suggest that the rise in temperature began around 1975, not in 1908 as Shaidurov claims. It's well known that ice fields were in retreat since the 1800s (Kilimanjaro and Glacier Bay, Alaska), but there was a small _decrease_ in temperatures during the twentieth century until about 1975. 1975 is what we climatologists call the "regime change", although with all that pesky noise in the signal it was hard to tell until about a decade later.

Correlation is not causation, but I agree with Shaidurov that correlation is a good place to start looking for causation.

My first reaction was that the Tunguska event was just not big enough. The world's climate system is BIG! One little pop like a 15 megaton explosion just isn't enough to change things drastically.

I should also point out that Vladimir Shaidurov's theory about the Tunguska Event is a good example of how science is supposed to work. Some crazy guy proposes a theory, publishes the evidence, and everybody else gets to bang on it to see if the theory stands or falls. Next time I will be the crazy guy proposing a new theory. Everybody is supposed to get a fair hearing.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Kevin Murphy published on March 15, 2006 12:34 PM.

Missing the Real Story was the previous entry in this blog.

Are All Creeds Created Equal? is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

LINKS


St. Louis Blogs:

J Bowen
Christopher Johnson
Charles Austin
Archpundit
Random Observations
Brian J Noggle
Shelley Powers
Gateway Pundit
Listless Lawyer
Jim Durbin
Timothy Birdnow
Diane Meyer
Marijean Jaggers
Scott Ginsberg
Steve Boriss
St. Louis Bloggers
St. Louis Blogs . Org
Randall Sherman
Urban Review STL

Missouri Blogs:

John Combest
Blue Girl, Red State
Another Rovian Conspiracy
The News Buckit
The Source
Fired Up! Missouri
Susan "Farmgirl"

Favorite Blogs:

James Lileks
Glenn Reynolds
Rich Galen
Megan McCardle
Scrapple Face
In The Agora
The Brothers Judd
Geitner Simmons
Cronaca
Science Blog
Winds of Change
Da Goddess
Justin Katz
Fran Mason
Phil Carter
Greg Costikyan
Tom McMahon
Kevin Aylward
Rand Simberg
Michael Totten
Belmont Club
News Busters
Mark Ciocco
David Weinberger
Tom Maguire
Jon Henke & McQ (plus Dale!)
Kevin Murphy The Other
Craig Henry
Brian Tiemann
Crooked Timber
Charles Johnson
Powerline
Busy Mom
Jason Van Steenwyk
Jenne
INDC Journal
Eamonn Fitzgerald
John Little
King of Fools
Perish the Thought
Patterico
Jeff Harrell
Michael Yon
Ed Driscoll
George Roper
Jeff Goldstein
Mark A. R. Kleiman
David Opderbeck
Libertas
Bob Somerby
Ben Witherington
Creative Bits
Mark Daniels
Michael Spencer
Think Sink
The Brussels Journal
A J Strata
S K Murphy
Joe Carter
John Hawkins
Bridget
Back Talk
Joe Sherlock
Mark Perry
Daniel Dilger

Pundits

Charles Le Kraut Martel
Victor Davis Hanson
Mark Steyn
Thomas Sowell
Malcolm Gladwell
Robert Cringely
John Carroll
Paul Graham
David Nicklaus

My Interests

The Paralyzed Veterans of America
The American Anti-Slavery Group
Wayside Gardens
The Alliance for the Separation of
School and State

MacSurfer Daily News
Urban Legends
Diablo II Net (Unofficial)
The Word Detective
HotAIR
UN Documentation Center
Cub Scout Pack 787
Baloo's Bugle (Cub Scouts)
Wounded Warrior Project
Operation Iraqi Freedom
Defense Industry Daily